Hey Imminst. Pike here.
Some of you might remember me from my former log I used to keep on here with my back-and-forth battle with ADHD and my turn to nootropics in order to look for a more long-term treatment.
Well, on the behalf of my academic career, I'd like to say, thank you ImmInst. Since starting here, perusing the forums, and finding out what information I can about various nootropics, cognition/clarity enhancers, general life practices, I have:
- raised my GPA by .5
- made immense progress in discovering my body's individual chemistry
- made immense progress on a (still developing) LIFE regimen to assist with my ADHD (not just relying on supplements)
- been accepted into the University of California schooling system on, essentially, a full ride
- learned tons of... well... fun information that I find myself incorporating into my life.
With that said, here is my review of supplemets I've taken over the past few months in addition to my current regimen for the purpose of treating ADHD.
So, review of all supplements taken (listed in no particular order):
Piracetam - A one hit wonder. Just got lucky with this one and has never left my regimen.
Aniractam - Although literature says it does not build up in one's system, i've definately found that its effects do. Love it.
Alpha GPC - Supposedly a fantastic choline source, I found it no better than any of the other ones i tried.
Lecithin - Poor choline source, but super duper amazing for adding to a shake that happens to have myriad water and fat soluble nootropics for its emulsifying properties. Definately seems to help absorb the fat-soluble ones more.
Sulbutiamine - I think I will always carry a sweet spot for this nootropic and will miss having it terrible. As a side note, as effective as it was (definately amont the most helpful, if not the most) it was easily THE most foul thing i've ever tasted. There was never one time I put this into a shake and didn't gag.
Centrophenoxine - My favorite "choline source" nootropic. I'm aware that it's commonly regarded as a mere choline source, however, in my opinion, it's DEFINATELY a nootropic of its own that happens to also be a choline source.
Idebenone - Another one of my early favorites. At the 6-8 week mark, you really start seeing a difference in mental clarity. It's anti-coagulant+cerebral blood flow enhancing abilities are definately not things to be brushed off, however. Too much of this paired up with my other noots sometimes gave me spontaneous nosebleeds.
Ginkgo Bilboa - Oh dear god, I am never trying this again. Perhaps it was because I used an unstandardized extract tea, however, within a week of using this, I began experiencing symptoms of vitamin B6 deficiency. I later found that it carried an antivitamin b6 NEUROTOXIN. Never touching it again.
Pyridoxamine - A completely-out-of-the-blue help. I experimented with it because I was aware that those with ADHD typically have B-vitamin deficiencies and I had already been taking b-vitamins as a regular part of my day-to-day regimen. Surprisingly, it seemed to add an extra "kick" to my regimen.
Huperzine A - Helpful for memory. Very. In terms of focus: Not at all. I only use it because it acts as an NMDA antagonist and I don't like drinking copious amounts of magnesium all day on the days that I use stimulants.
Galantamine - Feels like Huperzine and a 5 hour cigarette. Slightly better focus, but not particularly.
Nicotine (in cigarette, gum, and patch form) - cigarettes were by far the most useful for potentiating Adderall. On their own, not really helpful for focus. Gum was terrible (wanted to try lozenges but they were out). Patches reign #1 for nicotine administration in my book. I typically cut a 21mg patch into 4ths, or on days where I'd like to potentiate my Adderall, I'd cut it in half. BIG NOTE TO THAT: I am a former smoker, and I am sure that that much nicotine to a non-user would probably make you fall asleep.
Acetyl-L-Carnitine - Not bad. On a stimulant comparison, it's like 2.5mg of Adderall.
Alpha Lipoic Acid - Another surprising out-of-the-blue helper. I used it at first to try and synergize with the ALCAR. I found that it helped with focus more on it's own than alcar. However, the ALA+ALCAR combo did prove superior in the end.
CoQ-10 (ubiquinol form) - Didn't help. However, I wasn't expecting it to. Sure did help with my day-to-day energy levels. Tried it because Idebenone seemed to work so great for me.
Ginseng - Awesome on it's own. Only seems to synergize well with other herbs (i.e. adaptogens, immunogens, etc.). When paired with other non-herb nootropics, it seemed to diminish them greatly.
Ashwagandha - Put me to sleep. Terrible.
Bacopa Monierri - Seemed to make ADHD symptoms worse. Not touching it again.
Rhodiola Rosea - Definately something i took at night for a while. After about a month, it stopped putting me to sleep, and it helped with the constant daydreaming.
Green Tea: Tea by itself feels like a nootropic, extract doesn't.
Fish-Oil - Did see some benefits, but too mild to pinpoint to the EPA/DHA factor. Then again, I was using a very low-potentcy and low quality fish-oil. (costco-brand. meh.)
Modafinil - I know that literature supports it but it did nothing for me other than put my ADHD into overdrive. Feels like an energy drink and way too much niacin. Hate the stuff.
Vinpocetine - Awesome stuff. A nice short-term-memory buff and a little focus resembling that of a stimulant.
Desmopressin - <3 Good focus, but the memory boost is insane. Unreal. For 6-8 hours i have photographic memory. I'm not kidding. The day that I tried it I was able to remember even the smallest details, down to the number of buttons on the blouse that the pretty store clerk at Banana Republic was wearing, or something as wide as... all of the terms used in the covered chapters of my Biology test.
Hydergine - The best. To me, it's my super nootropic. It's a powerful nootropic all on it's own, it's easily potentiated, and it also seems to synergize with just about everything except modafinil (which really isn't a problem). When I use it with Addy, it's like a 2x magnifier, but takes off the jitters. When used with a noot-stack, same effect. It's my favorite nootropic I've ever tried and I would reccomend it strongly if it didn't carry that fibrosis risk (along with ergotism, of course).
Thus far, my favorite nootropics that I've tried are:
1) Hydergine
2) Sulbutiamine
3) Piracetam
4) Idebenone
5) Centrophenoxine
My regimen I take now consists of:
Piracetam - 1600mg x3
Aniracetam - 1000mg x3
Vipocetine - 5mg x3
Idebenone - 150mg x3
Alpha GPC - 400mg (w/breakfast)
Lecithin - 1200mg softgels x3 (180 Phosphatidyl Choline each)
Alpha Lipoic Acid - 200mg x3 (in sustained release form)
ALCAR - 1000mg x4
Fish Oil with 300mg of EPA/DHA total (yeah, crappy brand) - 1000mg softgels x3
NOTES:
- I miss Sulbutiamine terribly and will put it back into my regimen as a keeper the moment I use up some other things.
- I want to put Centrophenoxine back into my regimen, but there's a big concern I have for all this choline supplementing we seem to do...
- I still haven't tried Pyritinol, but don't plan to soon. Too expensive for my taste. If the price on bulk powder went down, or perhaps the amount I could get in bulk went up, I might give it a whirl.
- Willing to try Bromocriptine. Nicergoline seems okay, but it's just another cerebral blood flow enhancer, and I have enough of those. Cabergoline seems WAY too much.
- For those hard-on-the-tongue noots, get a capping kit. From what I can tell, the best noots are all the worst tasting. Cap-em-quick is utter crap unless you'd like to have early arthritus. Go with Capsule Machine if you're going to get one. Capsuline sells nice color capsules for those who like to color coordinate your supplements, or for those who don't like putting labels on everything.
- A MAJOR CONCERN I have about all of this choline supplementing we seem to do: seeing as choline was considered B-vitamin (b4 for those of you who weren't aware), and seems to have many of the properties of the b-family... wouldn't supplementing the copious amounts that we do (pretty carelessly at that) potentially create a serious imbalance of one's b-vitamins? I'm not exactly a bio-chemist or anything, but anyone who reads this forum long enough learns how delicate the b-vitamin family is, and that they all compete over one another for absorption. Any veteran posters care to elaborate?
- on the note of B-vitamins, I'm almost out of my b-complex. It was a low quality one that I bought On the shelf before I even knew about this site. Can anyone reccomend me to a generally "superior" B-complex I could buy? Preferrably, one that has either Pyridoxamine, Benfotiamine, Methyl B12, or LOW amounts of folic acid?
- Also, what benefits does an sustained-release b-complex have over a standard one? Most of the B-vitamins have such long half-lives anyway. Oh, an are there any sort of R-Lipoic-Acid sustained release forms? I am thorougly satisfied with ALA and would like to try RLA.
Sincerely,
Pike
Edited by Pike, 18 May 2009 - 04:57 AM.