People have often asked me:
Jonathan are psychedelics Nootropics?
I've done some preliminary research and I'm going to say NO.
While you could spend literally years (or decades) listen to all the podcasts singing the praises of psychedelics there’s good evidence for remaining skeptical of them.
- MAPS.org is the top resource for scientific study of psychedelics. The vast majority of the human research showing a positive result of using them is in trials involving addicts or those suffering from PTSD, the clinical evidence of them helping otherwise healthy people is scant.
- Pubmed lists no human clinical trials with a follow up investigation where a positive effect was noted on memory or cognition, which in contrast you can certainly find for Nootropics.
- Some research indicates impairments of memory and mental functions while dosed which is kind of what you would expect.
- The closest thing to research I could find on positive effects on personal transformation was two studies done in 2017. The first was done Assessing the Psychedelic "After-Glow" in Ayahuasca Users at the University of Barcelona which showed sustained elevations in nonjudging 2 months later in a five facet mindfulness questionnaire. The second, Effect of Psilocybin on Empathy and Moral Decision-Making interestingly found that Psilocybin significantly increased emotional, but not cognitive empathy and In contrast, moral decision-making remained unaffected by psilocybin. These studies would seem to confirm the stereotype of the hippy-dippy wu-wu psychedelic lover but don’t provide much evidence of them as transformational tools like mindfulness or brain training.
- There’s this rather terrifying phenomena of Hallucinogen Persisting Perception Disorder which means that auditory and visual hallucinations persist after a psychedelic experience for days, weeks or longer. And it doesn't just happen to hardcore psychonauts who are using excessive amounts of drugs and having jaring bad trips. It can happen after just one trip. There are over 40 science papers documenting HPPD so it’s not exactly a fringe phenomena.
Psychedelics don’t belong in the same risk-reward category as Nootropics.
Edited by jroseland, 29 October 2018 - 08:03 AM.