Replication of Turnbuckle breath-holding experiment
For my first posting in this online community, I'm replicating Turnbuckle’s breath holding experiment. I’m curious whether I can get similar results by using an even lower dose of c60oo than Turnbuckle used. I also believe, as Turnbuckle and others have suggested, that breath-holding durations may provide a simple and useful metric concerning one big effect of c60oo that many report. So let's get some data on this.
Some background: I’m a male in my late 40s. I have been taking c60oo (carbon60oliveoil brand) for 10 weeks at 7 to 14 day intervals (average interval about 9 days) at 1.5 mg to 2.5 mg per dose. So my lifetime total is around 20 mg.
My previous dose (2 mg) was 8 days ago.
I’ve more or less replicated the first 3 stages of Turnbuckle’s breath holding trial at 1/3 his dose. And for variation, 4 hours after first 1 mg, I took another 1 mg, thereby doubling the day’s dose.
I diluted the c60oo product even further with a known highest quality EVOO (4:1 ratio) and consumed the EVOO/c60oo solution with chickpeas and lentils.
I paused for about 1 minute between attempts, breathing normally, taking a deep exhale-inhale before starting. Measurements are in seconds.
In the results tabulated below, you’ll see some analysis I ran on the numbers. The percentages in brackets are percent increases in 4 measures at each test time vis a vis the control (T1). Specifically, at each testing (T2, T3, etc), I’ve calculated:
- the percent increase in "total seconds" across the three attempts over T1.
- the median of three attempts compared to median time at T1.
- the maximum time of three attempts compared to maximum time at T1.
- finally, I averaged the three above measures of % increase and named this new measure BQ or "Breath Quotient."
TURNBUCKLE - scores (and % increases over T1)
Sources: #823 and #824 in this thread
T1 (0 hours): 25, 35, 60, Tot=120, Median=35, Max=60
Consumed 3 mg
T2 (1 hours): 25, 55, 85, Tot=165 (38%), Median=55 (57%), Max=85 (42%), BQ = 45%
T3 (2 hours): 25, 65, 90, Tot=180 (50%), Median=65 (86%), Max=90 (50%), BQ = 62%
T4 (3 hours): Did not test
T5 (4 hours): Did not test
T6 (5 hours): XX, XX, XX, Tot=XXX (50%), Median=XX (86%), Max=XX (50%), BQ = 62%*
___
* Turnbuckle reports (post #824) "I retested after five hours from the 3-mg dose, and the results were the same as after two hours" (hence, I entered my calculations on his T3 numbers for T6).
EMPIRICUS - scores (and % increases over T1)
T1 (0 hours): 65, 75, 110, Total=250, Median=75, Max=110
Consumed 1 mg
T2 (1 hours): 125, 88, 78, Total=291 (16%), Median= 88 (17%), Max=125 (14%), BQ =16%
T3 (2 hours): 80, 150, 95, Total=325 (30%), Median= 95 (27%), Max=150 (36%), BQ = 31%
T4 (3 hours): 125, 112, 145, Total=382 (53%), Median=125 (67%), Max=145 (32%), BQ = 50%
T5 (4 hours): 110, 108, 120, Total=338 (35%), Median=110 (47%), Max=120 (9%), BQ = 30%
Consumed additional 1 mg
T6 (5 hours): Did not test
T7 (6 hours): 96, 125, 112, total= 333 (33%), Median 112 (49%), Max=125 (14%), BQ = 32%
T8 (10 hours): 120, 98, 94, Total=312 (25%), Median=98 (31%), Max=120 (9%), BQ = 22%
Holding my breath for 2 min 30 secs at 2 hours post c60oo is quite possibly my all time best ever — and I’ve been doing this experiment on and off since I was about 6 years old. I found holding my breath to be more comfortable during T3-T4 phases of this experiment than during most previous attempts to hold my breath. It just felt easier than usual.
Unlike Turnbuckle, my longest time isn’t dependably the last of three.
How much greater were Turnbuckle’s score increases on 3 mg compared to my own score increases on 1 mg? That's what these percentages show:
T2 Total (+21%), Med (+40%), Max (+28%), BQ (+30%)
T3 Total (+20%), Med (+59%), Max (+14%), BQ (+31%)
At T2 and T3, I was taking 1/3 as much c60oo as Turnbuckle. Turnbuckle’s performance gains outpaced mine by a margin of 31% (BQ), but I made up considerable ground at T4. Comparing our respective performance highs, Turnbuckle’s percentage increase peak measurements at 2 hours (T3) and 5 hours (T6) only exceeded my peak BQ score taken at 3 hours (T4) by 12%. How to account for having narrowed the gap so much?
Possibly the c60oo I took kicked in later on account of it being mixed with lentils. Another possibility is that 3 hours is the point at which c60oo has maximum effect on breath holding. Perhaps Turnbuckle’s performance gains would have destroyed mine at 3 hours had he tested then.
Other factors that may have contributed to my top max score at T3 and/or high BQ score at T4:
- Drank 3 cups of coffee with milk between T1 and T3
- I did 30 minutes of high intensity cardio after T2
- Ate 3 eggs (mainly yokes) after T3
I think I never got the cumulative bang of 2 mg, possibly because the effects of the first dose were wearing off by the time I took the 2nd dose. And with the 2nd dose, I neglected to do the test at the possibly optimal 3-hour post-dose point.
Probably re-doing this test over several days would provide an indication of the rate of decline of cardio and/or breath-holding benefits. Onward and upward!