Hi,
I've been reading this forum and looking up all this stuff for a while but seem to be getting confused and conflicting info.
I'm looking for some supplements for general anti-inflammatory effects as well as to help heal up some stubborn tendonitis. I'll also share with you what I've used and my experience with it.
Background on me: 31 year old male. Lifting weights since 18. Special considerations at bottom.
Here are the supplements that I am interested in:
ASTRAGALUS - According to one study I heard about, it improved endurance in rats, improved quality of life and reduced chemo induced fatigue in cancer patients by 50% (not sure if it would have a similiar effect on people who aren't doing chemo). Supposed to be anti-inflammatory.
My questions about this supplement are what exactly am I supposed to look for on the label? For example, consider these different brands:
Solaray
200mg - Astragalus(ASTRAGALUS MEMBRANACEUS)(ROOT EXTRACT)(GUARANTEED 70% {140 MG} POLYSACCHARIDES)
VitaminShoppe
500mg - Astragalus Membranaceus(Root)
(no info about standardization or amount of polysaccharides)
Nature's Plus
450mg - ASTRAGALUS(ASTRAGALUS MEMBRANACEUS ROOT)(STANDARDIZED TO 0.4% (1.8 MG) 4'-HYDROXY-3'-METHOXYISOFLAVONE 7-SUG)
(lol wut)
Nature's Way
333mg - Astragalus(ROOT)
Solgar
90mg - Astragalus Extract2:1 (Root)
350mg - Raw Astragalus Powder(Root)
etc.
Anyway, none of that means anything to me. How do I know which kind I'm supposed to use? Does standardization even matter? What is a 4'-Hydroxy-3'Methoxyisoflavone 7-Sug?
I'm well aware that when a supplement becomes popular, companies will just start making it and people will buy it because it has that supplement's name on the bottle without paying attention to if it's the leaf or root or whatever, standardization, etc. So I want to make sure I get the right stuff.
Also, Dr. Oz said Astragalus will prevent telomere shortening and you'll live longer. That would be a nice side effect.
GRAPE SEED EXTRACT - supposed to lower blood pressure (not an issue for me, see note below). Supposed to be a good anti-oxidant. I've heard that the methods used for extracting grape seed and pine bark extracts almost always include the use of organic solvents, which are toxic, and cannot be completely removed from the substances after the extraction process, and the consumer gets some toxic residue in the final product. That's not cool. Your thoughts on this? Is it worth taking as an anti-inflammatory?
ASTAXANTHIN - I'm having trouble finding legit info about this. Most of what I read are spam posts on forums talking about sunburn immunity and huge endurance increases and of course they're almost always accompanied by links to buy your own. *coughshillcough*. And then you've got the people who argue about Pfaffia Rhodozyma vs Haematococcus Pluvialis extract. It's infuriating that it's so hard to find legit info about supplements. A thread on this forum suggested that doses above 8mg may be associated with increased risk of lung cancer. I've also heard it can cause "shifts in hormone levels" although it wasn't specific as to how they were shifting, also reduced calcium levels, decreased libido and breast enlargement in men, although rare. Some sources say it is a good anti-inflammatory.
QUERCETIN - supposed to be a powerful flavinoid?
Any other suggestions for anti-inflammatory things???
Here's what I've used in the past:
BROMELAIN - Started with 500mg pills @ 600GDU. Took up to 3 per day, on an empty stomach (as recommended for inflammation). No effect. Increased to 500mg pills @ 2,000GDU. Caused heart palpitations. Later I found a warning online that you shouldn't take more than a certain amount (800mg? I don't remember) per day if you have a history of heart palpitations. Unfortunately, almost all Bromelain information talks about doses in mg which is useless without knowing the GDU. 500mg at 600 GDU is substantially less than 500mg at 2,000 GDU even though they're both 500mg. So saying "take 500mg of Bromelain" doesn't mean anything, nor is it a dose that can be recreated.
CURCUMIN - I used Vitamin Shoppe's brand cuz it had piperine mixed in which is supposed to increase the bioavailability by 2,000% or some ridiculous number like that. A single pill gave me diarrhea and killed my libido. No effect on pain. I emptied out half of a pill capsule and tried again. Diarrhea and loss of libido. I tried 1/4 of a pill. Diarrhea and loss of libido. No effect on pain ever. I stopped taking this. From what I learned on another forum, Curcumin is also an MAOI (although one without the "cheese effect") and can have a boost in mood. They also said that abrupt discontinuation can result in rebound inflammation and reinjury. All of this combined with the fact that it made me sick, took away my ability to get it up, and didn't do anything for the pain made me realize Curcumin is not a supplement for me.
MAGNESIUM - I know everyone loves magnesium, especially for tendonitis. Magnesium Taurate (Cardiovascular Research brand) seemed to reduce my pain. It also made me sleepy so I started taking it at night. I think that was the taurine, and sometimes I use 500mg of taurine as a sleep aid before bed. I later tried Magnesium Malate and Magnesium Glycinate, both of which gave me heart palpitations even at low dosages. They got so bad I went to a cardiologist who had me wear a ZioPatch (heart monitor) for 4 days. I was having upwards of 60 palpitations per day. About a week after stopping the magnesium, they finally went away. Scary. Do not want to try this again.
Special considerations - I have chronic tic disorder and take 1/4 of a 0.1mg Clonidine pill (that's a dose of 0.025mg) nightly. It's an alpha blocker blood pressure medicine that is used off label to treat tics. My blood pressure is normal to begin with, and the Clonidine makes it even lower, so sometimes if I stand up too fast I get dizzy. Why am I mentioning this? I do extra research on any supplement I consider trying to make sure it won't exacerbate tic disorders. For example, I cannot use steroids (including corticosteroids, and presumably ketosteroids (Cissus)), because they are known to exacerbate tics, sometimes significantly. I also have IBS and need to take it easy on my stomach. When I start a new supplement or medication I usually start with 1/4 of a dose just to check for tolerance and then slowly increase up to a normal dose.
Looking forward to your replies. Sorry for the novel-length post.
Edited by ironfistx, 27 September 2012 - 11:42 PM.