Aside from Kava, the only supplements with lots of scientific evidence are Ashwagandha and lavender like you mentioned, as well as high dose inositol. That is not to say these are the only supplements that are efficacious, but they are the only ones with a good deal of evidence to back up their use.
As far as mechanisms of actions go, Kava, honokiol and magnolol look the most promising. Theoretically the changes they make in the brain could reduce anxiety even when they aren't in your system anymore. So far the only human studies for magnolia have been on Relora, which is a low dose of magnolia with phellodendron amurense, and they have not been as promising as the previously mentioned supplements.
As far as personal experiences go, Kava has still been the most potent for me, followed by lavender( Silexan sold as 'Calm Aid'). Ashwagandha (I've tried KSM-66) i generally don't feel, lemon balm provides a much more noticeable effect but that's probably because it seems much more sedating than the other ones. Haven't tried high dose inositol.
Theanine and Rhodiola wont do a great job at reducing anxiety per se, but I understand why they've been mentioned in this context. Rhodiola is pretty decent for reducing the negative effects of chronic and acute stessors, theanine is good for relaxing stimulant jitters, neither will hold a candle to kava or lavender for acute anxiety reduction, cant say i've ever felt any anxiety eduction from schizandra. Theanine will definitely give you the most tangible change in mood of the 3. You might find it relaxing without having a huge effect on reducing anxiety, if that makes sense at all.
Thank you so much for your response.
Yeah, we both agree Kava is the best thing out there. But I've taken it only in Root Powder form, have you felt any feelings from capsules? At what doses? Many people say they don't feel much from capsules, but I wonder if it depends on the brand or what.
I get what you mean by theanine not helping much with anxiety but being calming. The stack i'm looking to make would ideally have both of these properties though (something like weed/alcohol without the bad effects). So maybe a combination of Kava, Lavender, Theanine (+caffeine?) and lemon balm could be a good stack? (Ashwaghanda has a lot of research behind it, but you said you didn't feel much from it so I don't know, maybe I could add it)
The problem is, I'm not used to making stacks but I know better than to just to take the effective dose of each ingredient and combine them, no? Wouldn't that be too much?
Effective dosages would be, as I understand:
Kava: 200-300 mg (with 30% kavalactone content), or more for a more powerful effect
Theanine: 200 mg
Lemon Balm: 500-600 mg
Lavender: It's tricky, most of the time it's found in oil format. Other than the product you mentionned which has 80 mg, there is one called Stress Relax Serenity Formula, which has 150 mg of a powder extract(??)
Valerian (which I forgot to mention in my first post for some reason, despite many people liking it): 500mg-1g
Ashwaghanda: 200-250mg
Would you agree these are the usual effective doses? But I don't know how to make a stack out of it. Taking the ED for each one seems like it could be too much
Thanks again boss
Edited by deon10, 10 November 2014 - 08:24 PM.